Considering Phenolic or Epoxy for your worktop or cabinetry application? Architects, B2B engineers and procurement personnel very often find themselves choosing between these two scientific surface solutions.
For a 1″ thick surface board, let’s take a look and compare 10 things you should consider between these two types of scientific surfaces when making a selection.
A black Epoxy resin board costs approximately 15% more per square foot than phenolic resin. Advantage: Phenolic.
2. Lead Time
Lead Time for standard colors of phenolic and Epoxy resin tops are 1 to 2 weeks. Advantage: Push.
Standard conditional warranty is 10 years for both phenolic resin and epoxy resin. Advantage: Push.
4. Color Options
Phenolic colors are the same price with the exception of speckled grey which is an up-charge.
Epoxy colors other than black fall into 3 tiers, each carrying an upcharge ranging from 10% to 25% over the previous tier. Advantage: Phenolic.
Epoxy resin surface tops have stood the test of time as the standard for lab-grade work surfaces for decades whereas phenolic resin surface tops are not as seasoned. Advantage: Epoxy.
Phenolic resin uses recycled wood fibers as the bonding agent for the resin which is non-toxic when fabricated whereas epoxy resin uses silica, which is a carcinogen that is toxic when fabricated. Advantage: Phenolic.
Epoxy resin can be more difficult and time-consuming to fabricate due to its heavier weight coupled with requiring diamond tipped tooling. Phenolic resin can be easier on machinery due to its wood fiber consistency and is able to be fabricated with standard wood tooling. Advantage: Phenolic
Phenolic resin weighs approximately 10 pounds per square foot whereas epoxy resin weighs over 11 pounds per square foot and more weight means spending more money on shipping costs. Advantage: Phenolic.
9. Chemical Resistance
Both surfaces are non-porous and highly resistant to chemicals. A comparison of chemical resistance of epoxy resin vs. phenolic resin yielded similar effects in many areas with the exception of certain (Acetone, Phosphoric Acid 85%, Sulfuric Acid 25% to 33%) where phenolic resin showed no detectable change in the material surface and epoxy resin showed slight detectable change in color/gloss but no change in function or life of the surface.
Sulfuric acid 96% showed slight detectable change in color/gloss but no change in function or life of the phenolic surface versus epoxy surface which showed an objectionable change in appearance due to discoloration or etching. Advantage: Phenolic.
10. Heat Resistance
Phenolic resin counter tops can withstand temperatures up to 350 degrees Fahrenheit whereas epoxy resin can handle temperatures over and above 350 degrees Fahrenheit, including some epoxy that can withstand temperatures up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit. Advantage: Epoxy.
That just about does it. Which one do you like using? Let us know in the comments.